Postby JLDoggett » Wed Oct 29, 2008 12:11 pm
Mike is using the same deductions as I when he comments on the shield befitting a trophy more than a piece made for the table. Were it made as a table piece, the shield would have been a grape-leaf (left plain for engraving) to be more harmonious with the rest of the cup. If the existing insert is removable it would need to be marked, and those marks should match the ones on the base. Otherwise, it is most likely a replacement. For so ornate a base one could expect an upper section to co-ordinate with it.
.