Postby blakstone » Sat Mar 28, 2009 11:34 pm
These do appear to be genuine pre-revolutionary Paris marks. The “A” is the large charge mark of tax farmer Henri Clavel, in use 31 Aug 1782 — 23 Feb 1789. The crowned “P” is the Warden’s mark, also called the date-letter, Jurande mark or Maison Commune mark. The last two digits of the year appear between the crown and the letter, but are very worn here; the shape of the letter, though, shows it be that of 1787 (which was actually used through most of 1788, from 11 Jul 1787 to 12 Nov 1788).
The mark you show blown up in the box is the large discharge (décharge) mark of Clavel’s successor Jean-François Kalandrin, used from 23 Feb 1789 — 20 Mar 1791. This is odd, because the discharge mark should be from the same period as the charge mark. It’s not impossible, however, that the spoon was started in November of 1788 and not finished until February of 1789; the charge mark was struck a piece in the rough, and the discharge mark only after it was finished.
Still, I keep trying to make out Clavel’s discharge mark out of the little mark next to (almost touching) the “A”, but it just doesn’t look like it to me. (It was called the “dog’s head”, though it actually looked more like a lion). I must confess I can’t think of what this little mark might be.
The remaining mark, though, is the maker’s mark, unfortunately so worn as to be completely illegible.
So I guess three out of five isn’t too bad, and at least enough to narrow it down to Paris, 1787/89.