Postby amena » Wed Oct 20, 2021 8:07 am
Would you ever recognize a lion rampant in a photo of the mark in the middle (above examples)?
No, I would never have recognized him precisely because he is NOT a rampant lion, nor a winged dragon.
The first time I came across this mark I thought it was a fake, as far as it was different from the design. Only later did I realize that it was the design that was wrong. This is the danger of the design: if it was taken from a badly struck or difficult to interpret trademark, it can lead to a completely misleading image.
I understand that in the old days, when the techniques of reproducing a photo in a book were very crude or very expensive, it was necessary to resort to drawing, but today photography, indeed a series of photographs is far preferable.
I think that with the advent of the internet, the handbooks of the brands will be able to be re-edited in digital form with one or better some photos of real punchings.
My humble opinion.