I have come to the conclusion it is either London 1789 or Possibly London 1809 or 1811. It is had to tell if the date letter is a capital 'O' or a capital 'Q'. The London mark and duty mark lead me to think it is either of these two (crowned leopard, duty mark bust facing to the right), but I am open to a more expert eye!
The Makers mark is difficult to ID, an I.-*something* into a rectangle or chamfered rectangle - there are several option for either date set, and with the poor imprint of the makers mark I can't be sure.
Any help or opinions would be appreciated!
Hallmark Photos

Date Mark in detail:

Maker mark in detail:

Item photo
