Postby wev » Mon Apr 23, 2007 5:00 pm
I would be interested to see some actual documentation that these were actually sold as cigarette holders originally. I can certainly see an enterprising antiques dealer calling them such, but only to make a more current (in the old days) use for them. Machine rolled cirgarettes did not appear until after 1881 and it remained a man's diversion for another decade (and who could honestly picture this goopy thing sitting at a man's elbow in the day?). By the time women began taking it up in large numbers, this stand would have been very far past its stylistic time -- it was already three decades old in the 1880s. On a practical point, the door compartments are a very poor design, unless they are a make do, as I said. You would need some dexterity to slip one out, to say nothing of the fact that the doors open in the wrong direction for the vast majority of right handed people.
Perhaps these were indeed marketed as you describe, but I have serious doubts they originally designed as such.
.